Skip to main content

MY MONA LISA

Juhar Kumari, mother of Juddha, oil painting by Tej Bahadur Chitrakar

For five hundred years after the completion of Leonardo da Vinci's masterpiece debate raged in art history circles on just who might the lady with the enigmatic smile be. Was she a historical figure or just a figment of da Vinci's imagination? Only in 2005 did experts at the University of Heidelberg ascertain that it was the painting of Lisa Gherardini, the wife of a wealthy businessman in Florence. Paeans galore have been written about her smile but the song by Nat King Cole best describes the enigma:

Mona lisa, mona lisa, men have named you
You’re so like the lady with the mystic smile
Is it only ’cause you’re lonely they have blamed you?
For that mona lisa strangeness in your smile?

Do you smile to tempt a lover, mona lisa?
Or is this your way to hide a broken heart?
Many dreams have been brought to your doorstep
They just lie there and they die there
Are you warm, are you real, mona lisa?
Or just a cold and lonely lovely work of art?

In our own family there is a mystery I am yearning to solve. The large portrait of the lady in a black Victorian dress has been hanging in our house since the time I was tall enough to look up at the high ceiling of my father's drawing room. The portrait is that of the mother of Maharajah Juddha Shumsher J. B. Rana, my grandfather and prime minister of Nepal, 1933 - 1946 A.D. She was the family matriarch. But who was she before she married Commander-in-chief General Dhir Shumsher Jung Bahadur Rana in 1873 A.D. and where did she actually come from?

I remember stories of how Dhir, during one of his many campaigns in India, had met and got attracted to my great grandmother, Juhar Kumari Devi. Dhir was already a family man back home with at least 2 married wives and junior wives. His children were already grown up. But he had decided nevertheless to bring his lady back home. He was also afraid that this might not sit well with his elder brother Maharajah Jung Bahadur Rana, prime minister of Nepal. How would the old tyrant react?

Juhar Kumari at an young age


Juhar Kumari in old age

Family tradition says that Juhar Kumari was from the noble house of the state of Kangra located in what is today the Indian state of Himachal Pradesh. Fort Kangra the largest fort in the Himalaya region and the oldest fort in India was once a part of Nepal having been conquered by the expanding Gorkha armies under General Amar Singh Thapa during the early 19th century from King Sansar Chand the Katoch ruler. Along with the armies went Nepalese ethnic population from the western hills of Nepal to settle there. The 'Nepalization' of this area took place between 1806-09 A.D. until a joint force of the Punjab under Maharajah Ranjit Singh and the Katoch ruler Sansar Chand succeeded in driving out the Gorkhas east of the River Sutlez. 

Kangra Fort today


General Dhir Shumsher had brought Juhar Kumari back to Nepal and wed her and a son Juddha was born 2 years later in 1875 A.D. in Narayanhiti Durbar in Kathmandu. His brother Jung Bahadur had accepted his new wife in the family in deference to Dhir's valour in the campaigns. General Dhir at his death bed gathered his senior sons and made them promise to list Juddha in the Roll of Succession to the hereditary title of Maharajah and prime ministership of Nepal. After the death of his father Dhir in 1884 A.D. the young Juddha was brought up by his eldest brother Bir Shumsher and, after the coup d'etat of 1885 A.D. having assumed the prime ministership, Bir had indeed fulfilled the promise and given due recognition to Juddha.

Today, besides these anecdotal stories, nothing more exists for us to trace Juhar Kumari's lineage back neither to Kangra nor to its nobility. I have even read articles on her saying that she was a Muslim girl from Oudh, perhaps from the noble houses there, vanquished by the Nepalese armies during the Indian Mutiny of 1857 A.D. In the puritanical 19th Century India it is as unlikely that devout Hindus of the Kshetriya caste would take a Muslim bride as a Muslim noble family would give their daughter in marriage to a Hindu prince.

Coming back to the portrait, just who is our Leonardo da Vinci? Mrs. Sangeeta Thapa the socialite and art curator called me a few years back to request that the portrait be displayed at the exhibition of the portrait artist Late Tej Bahadur Chitrakar. Indeed her sharp eyes had seen that the oil on canvas was painted by the first Nepalese artist to train in the art of European style of portrait painting. Maharajah Chandra Shumsher had personally selected Chitrakar and had him sent for a formal training in Calcutta for seven years, from 1921 to 1928 A.D. Even the dead artist's family did not know that this particular portrait so beautifully painted by Chitrakar existed - it was a great joy for me to have it displayed at NAFA gallery.

Perhaps someday a Rana history buff will unravel the mystery of her lineage. Whosoever Juhar Kumari might have been before her marriage to General Dhir Shumsher, she is the mother of Maharaja Juddha Shumsher J. B. Rana, prime minister of Nepal, 1933 - 1946 A.D., and the enigmatic portrait still finds its prideful place in the collection at my house, as my priceless Mona Lisa.

Maharajah Juddha Shumsher with mother Juhar Kumari Devi and his family


Comments

  1. An interesting enigma indeed. Perhaps some of the contemporary ladies from Kangra who have married other Ranas could shed light on this mystery.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Some stories,like the Mona Lisa, and I guess this one too are best left to be an enigma forever.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Ranaji,

    Jauhar Kumari is indeed a mysterious woman, but why brood over her caste if nearly all of the former royal family carry a significant proportion of her blood in their veins? It's easy to speculate that she was from a lower caste because her lineage is unknown and most historians seem to suggest it but the fact that the royal family were related to her meant that it was very difficult to publish such things back then, and now, thank to our education system, no one considers History a readable subject and I doubt if any research will be done upon her. However, thanks to people like you there's always something to hope.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very interesting...
    So still a mystery....

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Hippies, Hashish and 'Hare Rama Hare Krishna'

  Hippies, Hashish and 'Hare Rama Hare Krishna' - Kami Kanetsuka Kami Kanetsuka is a traveller and writer based in V ancouver, Canada. During the 1960s and ‘70s, she travelled all over South East Asia and lived in Nepal for many years. I did a piece on her husband's restaurant and posted it on by blogsite earlier. https://historylessonsnepal.blogspot.com/2012/08/eating-around-world-in-kathmandu-first.html  ********************** Kathmandu in the 1960s and ‘70s was a serene, peaceful and cosmopolitan place that attracted travelers, seekers and filmmakers. A still from "Hare Rama Hare Krishna" The year 1971 was marked with several ‘big victories’ – in politics, cricket and in war – all of which had long term implications for India. The national mood was buoyant, even if the country continued to struggle with endemic problems.   Fifty years later, we look back at those times and evoke some of that mood.  In a series of articles , leading writers recall and analyze ...

THE MAHARAJAH'S LAST REPOSE

T he maharajah was having a nightmare. He often did since he left the hurly burly of Nepalese politics for a life of a raj-rishi with determination to devote the remaining few years of his life in spiritual pursuit. He dreamt of a calamity striking Nepal and taking him in its wake. Although not residing in Kathmandu any longer, he was still close enough to feel the ripples of a revolution should it come sooner or later, but come it would. The maharajah woke up sweating. He asked his attendant to light up his hookah. This would make him calm again. Ridi Bazaar on the banks of Kali Gandaki River Ridi is a very holy place in Nepal. Located at the confluence of the small Ridi stream and the larger Kali Gandaki River in Gulmi district, the site is acclaimed far and wide as a pilgrimage site as holy as Benaras. Throughout the ages pilgrims not able to reach faraway Benaras flocked to Ridi for salvation. The famous temple of Rishikesh founded by King Mukunda Sen graces the site. Nearb...

INTO THE MAELSTROM - JUNG BAHADUR LEADS AN ARMY

G overnor General Lord Canning's request to Jung Bahadur to assist the British militarily in Avadh sent a maelstrom through the court of Nepal. Prime Minister Bhimsen Thapa's war was still fresh in peoples' mind and the wound of Sugauly had not yet healed. The pacifists wanted to stay neutral saying it was not our fight. The powerful conservative faction still smarting from the earlier defeat wanted to fight the British instead by reinforcing Begum Hazrat Mahal. Maharajah Jung Bahadur was a brave-heart but he had first-hand witnessed the might of Britain; he knew that it was not the time to fight them. Too, he disliked the duplicity of the Indian rajas and the decadence of the Avadhi court where, until recently, Nawab Wajid Ali Shah was ruling the roost. He had also heard of savage killing of British civilians, women and children too, anathema to the chivalrous Jung. But decision to go to war is always a soul-searching affair. Jung held counsel with h...